TJA1050 vs. MCP2551: Surface Mount, High-Speed CAN Transceivers

CAN bus transceiver signals

CAN bus transceiver signal lines

If you design and develop electronics systems, you likely encounter buzzwords such as IoT, Industrial IoT (IIoT), or Industry 4.0. These terms refer to the use of advanced technologies within production systems or operating environments that utilize remote communication. For production, communication may be between machines located within the same facility or between different factories. Operationally, IoT based systems typically involve communications to and from the cloud. In either case, the objective is to create ever-smarter systems. 

The concept of making systems smarter by inter-networking is not new. In fact, production lines, aerospace platforms, and automotive vehicles have relied on the controller area network or CAN bus transceiver lines to achieve the same outcome for decades. The speed and range of connections or nodes that can be inter-networked using CAN transceivers has resulted in the widespread usage of CANs to increase the functionality and capability of electronic-based systems in industries as diverse as hospitals and railway systems. 

The major advantage to using CAN transceivers is the ability to communicate with both analog and digital devices over long distances through a single low-cost device. Let’s compare two high speed CAN transceivers, the TJA1050 vs. the MCP2551. 

The TJA1050 CAN Transceiver

The TJA1050 is one of many CAN modules available from NXP Semiconductors. This component has been a staple of NXP’s transceiver options for over two decades and has established a track record of successful implementation and reliability. 

Key Features of the TJA1050: 

  • Speed up to 1 Mbps
  • Low Electromagnetic Emission (EME) due to optimal matching for CANH and CANL
  • High Electromagnetic Immunity (EMI)
  • Compatible with 3.3 V and 5 V components
  • Thermal protection
  • Short-circuit proof
  • Transient protection (for automobile environments)
  • 110+ node connection capability

The TJA1050 has been developed for optimal performance even in noisy environments. This component is fully compatible with the prevailing standard for high-speed CAN applications,  ISO 1198 Road vehicles — Controller area network (CAN) — Part 1: Data link layer and physical signaling and operates in conjunction with a CAN protocol controller, providing differential transmit (to the bus) and receive (to the controller) capabilities.

For optimal design using this component, CAD information is available for download, as shown below. 

 Symbol, footprint, and 3D model for the TJA1050

TJA1050 downloadable CAD data

For additional technical information, including recommended circuit configurations, see the TJA1050 datasheet.

The MCP2551 CAN Transceiver

Another CAN transceiver that is often implemented is the MCP2551 from Microchip Technology. Introduced in 2001, this ISO 1198 compliant component has three operating modes: 1–High-Speed, 2–Slope-Control, and 3–Standby. 

The MCP2551 provides the following network protections:

  • Short circuit protection
  • Transient protection
  • Output overcurrent (by thermal shutdown)
  • MInimal emissions in High-Speed or Slope-Control modes
  • High noise immunity

As listed above, the MCP2551 can operate where high levels of EMI may be present. Additionally, this part can connect up to 112 nodes, transmit at 1 Mbps, and is compatible with 12 V and 24 V systems, which are typical in automotive systems. To promote the most accurate and efficient design, the device symbol, footprint, and 3D model are readily accessible, as illustrated below. 

Symbol, footprint, and 3D model for the MCP2551

MCP2551 downloadable CAD data

Microchip has published an extensive MCP2551 datasheet that should be consulted when implementing this component in your design

Now, let’s compare the TJA1050 vs. the MCP2551 for important parameters to aid you in selecting the best high-speed CAN transceiver for your product. 

Comparing the TJA1050 vs. the MCP2551 

Both the TJA1050 and MCP2551 are commonly utilized, reliable transceivers that can be used for high-speed CAN communications. In the table below, the two components are compared for a set of attributes that should inform your decision about which is most appropriate for your project. 

Designing With the TJA1050 vs. the MCP2251
Attribute/Parameter TJA1050 MCP2551
Lifecycle Status Active Active*
Package Type SO8 SOIC
Package Dimensions (w x l x h) 6.2 x 5.0 x 1.75 mm 6.0 x 4.9 x 1.75 mm
Node Connections 110+ 112
Transmission Rate 1.0 Mbps 1.0 Mbps
Supply Voltage 4.75 – 5.25 V 4.5 – 5.5 V
Supply Current 25.0 – 75.0 mA 75.0 mA (max)
Temperature Range -40.0 °C (min) -40.0 – 85.0 °C
EMI Protection Circuitry Yes Yes
ISO 1898 Compliant Yes Yes
RoHS Compliant Yes Yes

* Microchip recommends the MCP2561 for new designs.

As the table above clearly demonstrates, both the TJA1050 and MCP2551 are good candidates for existing designs. In addition to similar electrical parameters, both components are available in SMT packages with virtually identical profiles; therefore, opting for either as replacement parts for previous designs should be sufficient. For new designs, your specific performance requirements and objectives should guide your choice. 

If you’re looking for CAD models for common components, such as the TJA1050 or MCP2551 CAN transceivers, Ultra Librarian helps by compiling all your sourcing and CAD information in one place. Working with Ultra Librarian sets up your team for success to ensure any design is going through production and validation with accurate models and footprints to work from. Register today for free.

 

UL-Icon.png

The Ultra Librarian Team

Ultra Librarian offers the world’s largest PCB CAD library, putting cutting-edge materials at your fingertips so you can build better products faster—all for free.

Related Posts

If you’re looking for any of our component footprints or models, we have readily available and free options for you and your design team. Search our library for the solution you’ve been looking for.

Free Design Resources

Ultra Librarian is the worlds largest online – and always free – PCB CAD library. Build products better, faster, and more accurately with easy access to vendor-verified symbols, footprints, and 3D models. Register today to start searching the right components for your next design.

Recommended